Programmed by Jürgen Ellinghaus
Andreas Horvath’s film takes a dramatic look at the effects of the 2001 foot and mouth outbreak in North Yorkshire. It questions why culling was used instead of vaccination to stop the disease spreading. Did the Labour government have a hidden agenda to decrease the number of English farmers?
“It comes from above”, says one of the people who talk to the filmmaker, and ‘above’ is represented by the Army, the Police, vets and teams of liquidators followed by mechanical diggers and trucks. The executors/those executing the law leave behind them landscapes devoid of any trace of the abundant herds of before. All that remains for the farmers, defenceless, despairing and dispossessed of their main livelihoods, is to trust in something ‘higher’ still – the Heavens. The director, kept at a distance by fences and barriers, captures the macabre spectacle, his camera trembling (in dread?). By subtly alternating bucolic images and scenes of abominable slaughter, and his mise en abyme with a painting by the Romantic landscape artist Constable and, sound-wise, the polyphony of voices and prayers converging in a tragic choir, Andreas Horvath bestows his film with a unique genre. It’s a requiem, a liturgy on modern times with an Agnus Dei that’s a very real animal sacrifice, but one without a glimmer of hope, or peace, or mercy.